Interested in too many guys!?

I'm not seeing a problem here...

You don't have to pick one right away. Spend time with all of them either just as friends or casually dating.  As long as you don't lead them on and are clear that you aren't ready to commit there's no harm in it.  Eventually one will stand out above the rest.

The crazy thing about the sexual liberation period of the 60s is that it has resulted in a society that *more* restrictive in sexual relationships. In the old days, unless you were engaged, that meant you were free to play the field. But now people think if they have coffee with a guy, they're being unfaithful to go out with someone else! Or they think if they have sex, they're in a "relationship", and so after they have a few drinks and have sex one night, they think they are under all the restrictions of marriage.

Your lucky to have a number of nice guys whose company you enjoy so - enjoy! You should just go out with as many as you want. Keep doing that until you find the one you like best! And if you have to date several simultaneously, that's their problem! Tell them you're going out with others, and you're looking for the right one.  If they don't like it, let them lift their game!